A “Confused Creation”

The average television viewer in America would probably think themselves pretty savvy. They know what’s good and they certainly know an advertisement when they see it. Good, advertisers are counting on it. That’s why they’ve been changing their tactics for some time.

Although you may not notice, advertisers are flooding your television screen, just hoping to get your attention, subtly of course. In her 1991 article Doreen Carvajal reports on a local Philadelphia news station who replaced and episode of their local news a “special” health report shot at and sponsored by a local hospital. This raises some ethical concerns. Of all the people on Television, don’t the news shows have a sort of civil duty to bring you the truth? I guess it depends on their sponsors. In that same article the news station even talks about replacing their local news with a show entirely dedicated to shopping at local businesses. Thirty solid minutes of advertising sounds pretty good to the station. It assures them more money than some local news show that gets low ratings. But what about the viewer at home? What if this happened in a smaller city without only a couple of local news shows? It could severely affect what information was readily available to the public. Important stories could go un-aired. But at least you’d know where to get the best produce. At least you wouldn’t miss a single sale. At least you’d be a well trained consumer.
That was in 1991.

Today it might go something like this:

700 Club Screen Shots

That’s called the 700 club. It airs on ABC Family.The 700 club’s “show” is an infomercial. That is to say it’s a really long commercial.  In his article, “Advertising: The Magic System”, Raymond Williams states that in advertising an object “must be validated, if only in fantasy, by association with social and personal meanings.” The 700 Club associates admission to their club with spiritual gain. They’re mostly promoting their club for about an hour. The show sort of claims to be part news and part charitable organization doing it’s job. What’s their job? Letting Americans buy their salvation. Of course, why wouldn’t I buy my spirituality the same place I watch “Whose Line is it anyway?” reruns. It’s perfect. Get your worldly fix at 8 and call in at 9 to buy back your soul. You’ll be saved by bed time.

I’ll end with a quote from Raymond Williams article: “Most advertising is not the cool creation of skilled professionals, but the confused creation of bad thinkers and artists.”

700 Club Website
ABC Family Contractually obligated to air 700 Club
Carvajal, Doreen “Is It News, Ad, Or Infomercial”
Williams, Raymond “Advertising: The Magic System”

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to A “Confused Creation”

  1. bboessen says:

    While 700 Club is not the most current of targets to be taking on, the fact that it still airs in 2011 is certainly something to address. A more in-depth look at the series might start with an analysis of a segment from the program, drawing out specifics to support your argument here (that even the news they report on is still directed toward purchasing membership in their church).

    Perhaps a topic for your final project?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s